Originally published in The Muse.
George Clooney is one of the most recognizable stars in the world, and one of the most likeable. He’s next in the line of Clark Gable and Cary Grant — the dashing and funny gentleman with charisma dripping out his ears. In his new movie, Confessions of a Dangerous Mind, Clooney is as charming as ever, except this time, he’s behind the camera.
Confessions is based on the “unauthorized autobiography” of TV producer Chuck Barris (Sam Rockwell). Barris is the man behind such 70s staples as The Dating Game and The Newlywed Game, but his biggest hit was as host of The Gong Show.
Well, The Gong Show was his biggest TV hit. According to the movie, Barris was also responsible for the deaths of 33 people while employed as an assassin for the CIA.
Sound a little strange? Maybe that’s because screenwriter Charlie Kaufman is behind the script. The Charlie Kaufman who wrote Adaptation. and Being John Malkovich. The Charlie Kaufman who I described, in my review from two weeks ago, as being “out of his freakin’ mind.”
But this time, Kaufman has little to do with the weirdness. Everything about being a CIA operative comes straight from Barris’ book. It is true? Barris seems to think so, or at least doesn’t care if he fictionalizes his entire life. It doesn’t matter so much anyway, because this is still a fascinating, if flawed, movie, regardless of the facts.
Told in flashback as Chuck sits in a mangy motel writing his story, the movie flows through his life: he begins working at NBC as a page, and makes his way further and further up the ladder until he’s producing shows. One night he meets his love interest, Penny (Drew Barrymore), and while they aren’t really “together” throughout the movie, she always remains a major force in his life.
Then one night, after being pounded in a bar fight, he’s recruited by the government, and uses his job as chaperone of The Dating Game to hunt down spies in exotic date locations like Helsinki and West Berlin. What the fuck?
As awkwardly interesting as the plot is, the way it’s done is even more so. This movie has more style in one frame than just about anything else being made today. Clooney is having a ball, casting his friends in cameos, and experimenting liberally with camera tricks. He didn’t need to make a movie, he wanted to, and that gives him a certain amount of freedom. If it’s a commercial flop, who gives a rat’s ass?
The cinematography is nutty. In some very long takes, Clooney has his characters pop up in different places, in different costumes. One shot has the camera zoom in on Chuck’s eyes while in his house, and when it zooms out, he’s talking to his boss in his office. It seemingly defies the laws of physics. But regardless of how good it’s done, the style sometimes calls too much attention to itself, and takes away from the story. There’s so much cool stuff happening that before you can process one thing, another incredible thing has happened. It’s awesomeness overkill.
If you’ve ever seen Clooney interviewed, you know he’s funny, and his sense of humour comes through in Confessions more clearly than ever. But, it’s such a confusing sense of humor. A lot of the time, I wasn’t sure if I was supposed to be laughing or not. Forget whether I was supposed to — I wasn’t sure if I found it funny. I laughed at a soldier being hit in the throat by his superior, but I also spent a lot of time with my brow furrowed, scratching my head.
Lots of people won’t like this, for lots of reasons: too weird, too silly, too painfully visual — not funny enough, not serious enough, not whatever. People were walking out all over the place on Saturday night. That’s really a shame, because had they sat back and relaxed a little, they might have gotten a kick out of some of it. I’m not sure if I really liked it, but I definitely appreciated it.
If he keeps taking chances like this, and tones it down a little, George Clooney is going to be a great director. He’s already crafting a style all his own, but right now it’s a little muddled and a little forced. Through all the impossible tracking shots, and fun trick photography, the best part of the movie is just seeing Chuck let loose and dance during a taping of The Gong Show. It’s the simplest scene in the movie — and also the best. It’d be nice for Clooney to know that.